Should I Renovate or Move? A Contractor’s Perspective

If you’re like many homeowners in Johnson County, KS or the surrounding Kansas City Metro, you’ve probably asked yourself at some point:“Should we renovate our current home—or is it time to move?”

At Made New Home Services, we work with homeowners on both sides of that question. And while there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, there are some important factors to consider when making this decision. As local remodeling contractors with years of experience in home transformations, we’re here to help you think through the pros and cons from a practical—and professional—perspective.

Why Homeowners in Johnson County Are Asking This Now

With real estate prices still high and inventory limited in areas like Overland Park, Olathe, Leawood, and surrounding neighborhoods, many families are reconsidering the idea of moving. On the flip side, aging homes may need updates to better suit your lifestyle—and renovations can feel like a big commitment.

Here’s how to think it through.

The Case for Renovating

If you love your neighborhood, your school district, or your lot size, remodeling may be the smarter choice.

✅ Pros of Remodeling:

• Customize your space exactly how you want it

• Avoid the costs and stress of moving

• Add value to your home with high-ROI updates

• Stay in the location you love

We often remodel kitchens, bathrooms, and basements for clients who say, “We just need this house to work better for our family.” With the right plan, your current home can feel brand new.

Common Renovations in the KC Metro:

• Kitchen remodels in Olathe and Overland Park

• Bathroom updates in Prairie Village

• Basement finishing in Lenexa and Shawnee

• Whole-home makeovers across Johnson County
  

When It Might Make Sense to Move

In some cases, the cost of renovation might approach the value of simply finding a new home that already has what you need—especially if:

• You’re looking for a major increase in square footage

• Your home has structural issues or layout limitations

• You're changing school districts or moving for work

• You want a fresh start in a different part of the metro

Important tip: Before you decide to move, be sure to factor in realtor fees, closing costs, potential renovations in the new home, and moving expenses.

Ask Yourself These Questions:

1. Do I love my current neighborhood?

2. Is my home’s layout fixable with a remodel?

3. How long do I plan to stay in this home?

4. Would remodeling give me the space and features I need?

5. What’s my budget—and what would that budget get me if I moved?
   

Made New Home Services Can Help You Decide

As trusted residential remodeling contractors based in Johnson County, KS, we’ve helped countless families weigh the pros and cons of renovating vs. relocating. Sometimes a custom kitchen remodel or home addition can solve your biggest frustrations. Other times, a move might be the right call—and we’ll be honest about that, too.

If you're on the fence, we’d be happy to schedule a free consultation to walk through your space and help you explore your options. No pressure—just professional guidance from a team that knows the local housing market and the real cost of renovations.

Thinking about renovating your home in Johnson County or the Kansas City Metro?Contact Made New Home Services today to start the conversation. Your dream home might be the one you already live in.

📍 Proudly serving Olathe, Overland Park, Leawood, Shawnee, Prairie Village, and beyond.